Scope 2 Emissions Accounting: Double Counting, Deliverability, and Additionality

  • Typ:Bachelor's thesis
  • Betreuer:

    Zulaiqa Riduan

  • Zusatzfeld:

    2026

  • Market-based Scope 2 energy accounting allows companies to report carbon emissions based on contractual instruments such as renewable energy certificates or power purchase agreements. The current GHG Protocol revisions discuss whether market-based accounting should be retained, restricted or replaced. This study contributes to that debate using a Systematic Literature Review to examine the central problems double counting of clean energy, missing additionality and insufficient deliverability. In a next step the thesis translates the findings of the literature to a qualitative instrumental case study modelling three fictional companies located in Germany, Norway and Poland. A consultant character applies the current GHG Protocol rules and then modifies one assumption at a time: replacing the average grid factor with an estimated residual emission factor, enforcing hourly and geographical matching, and applying a weighted additionality score consisting of different tests. The main finding of the case study is the trade-off between double counting and real-world emission reductions. The study then concludes that the three problems require separate solutions and that none of the analysed instruments is sufficient on its own. The GHG Protocol should therefore require centrally published residual factors, stricter deliverability criteria, operational additionality tests, and a clear separation between inventory accounting and real-world impact accounting.